Visits
Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture
The SPT may visit any place under the jurisdiction of a State party where persons may be being deprived of their liberty. This includes, but is not limited to:
- police stations;
- prisons (military and civilian);
- detention centres (e.g. pre-trial detention centres, immigration detention centres, juvenile justice establishments, etc.);
- mental health; and
- social care institutions.
It recommends action to be taken to improve the treatment of detainees, including conditions of detention.
The visits are conducted by at least two members of the SPT. These members may be accompanied, if needed, by experts of demonstrated professional experience and knowledge in the field. These experts are selected from a roster of experts prepared on the basis of proposals made by States parties, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and the United Nations Centre for International Crime Prevention. Each State Party may propose up to five national experts as members of the roster.
Depending on the type of visit and the local circumstances of the country visited, the size of delegations may vary, as may the length of the visit, a country visit usually lasting around 10 days.
Visit reports
Types of visit
In order for the SPT to fully realize its mandate under the OPCAT, the SPT has so far devised four types of visits. These are:
SPT country visits
First, the SPT notifies the State party concerned in writing in advance of the planned dates of a visit. The SPT also notifies the State party in writing of the names of the SPT members who will take part in the visiting delegation, the names of external experts who will assist the delegation, as well as the names of the members of the SPT Secretariat who will support the delegation. The SPT requests information to be provided in advance of the visit, as detailed in the list of official information requested from States parties.
When undertaking such visits, the SPT draws on:
- Outline of a regular SPT visit
- Guidelines on visits to States parties (CAT/OP/5)
- Obligations of States parties (CAT/OP/24/1)
The SPT delegation carries out the visit according to the principle of co-operation and maintains strict confidentiality concerning its work and its findings.
During the visit, the SPT delegation meets with senior officials of the Ministry responsible for law enforcement (police) and with senior officials of the Ministries responsible for the custody of persons held in pre-trial detention, prison, military detention, immigration detention, psychiatric or social care institutions, or any other place of deprivation of liberty. The meetings are scheduled in consultation with the liaison officer(s) for the visit.
The SPT delegation also meets with the NPM(s), if already set up, and discusses all aspects of the establishment and functioning of the NPM(s). If the process of setting up the NPM(s) is still occurring, the delegation meets with persons involved in its establishment. The SPT takes the view NPM development is an on-going process which the SPT will continue to monitor.
The SPT also meets with national human rights institutions (NHRIs) and non-governmental organisations (NGOs), as well as with others who have information relevant to the SPT's mandate.
The SPT visits a variety of places of deprivation of liberty and speaks in confidence with persons held there and with staff and other persons involved in work relating to such places.
At the end of the visit, the SPT delegation has a final meeting with senior officials of the relevant ministries and bodies. The meeting is an opportunity for the SPT delegation to present its preliminary observations and for a confidential discussion concerning the visit, including issues related to the national preventive mechanism(s) and to the treatment of persons deprived of their liberty in places visited. This meeting is an opportunity to identify issues and situations requiring immediate action, as well as other elements of law and practice requiring improvement in order to reinforce the safeguards for persons deprived of their liberty against ill treatment. The authorities may wish to provide immediate feedback on some issues.
The SPT issues a brief written press release indicating that a SPT visit has taken place to the State party concerned, with a list of the SPT members in the visiting delegation and the persons accompanying them. The press statement indicates that the SPT met with senior officials of the Ministries listed, with representatives of the NPM(s) or potential NPM(s), with NHRIs, NGOs and others and that the SPT visited the places of detention listed.
After the SPT visit
After the visit, but before the adoption of the visit report, the authorities will be invited to provide information about developments since the visit in relation to some of the issues raised during the final talks.
A confidential report on the visit is subsequently drawn up and adopted by the SPT for transmission to the State party. The State party is requested to respond to the recommendations made in the report and to any requests for further information according to a timetable specified in the letter of transmission accompanying the report. The SPT visit report remains confidential until the State party requests its publication, together with any comments the State party might wish to make.
The SPT is committed to co-operative and productive working relationships with the States parties.
SPT country follow-up visits
The Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture (SPT) may also undertake short follow-up visits.
Such follow-up visits may be carried out following an SPT country visits and provide the SPT with the opportunity to learn of developments and see how its recommendations have been implemented. During such visits the SPT will meet with the national authorities, the National Preventive Mechanism, representatives of civil society in additional to visiting places where persons are deprived of their liberty.
After the visit, a follow-up visit report is drawn up. The report is transmitted in confidence to the Government, and forms the basis of a dialogue between the SPT and the State concerned. The follow-up visit report will be made public should the State give its permission.
NPM Advisory visits
In accordance with its mandate set forth in Article 11(b) of the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (OPCAT), the SPT undertakes Advisory visits to National Preventive Mechanisms (NPMs).
During its Advisory visits to NPMs, the SPT seeks to support and reinforce the NPM’s mandate by assisting the NPM and the State party through the provision of technical advice and assistance regarding its effective functioning and through practical capacity-building activities.
Generally, Advisory visits to NPMs allow the SPT to focus on the legal and practical framework within which the NPM is working and enables the SPT to engage directly both with the NPM, as well as other national institutions and civil society to learn more about its work in practice. Such visits usually include meetings with a broad range of governmental and civil society groups as well as with the NPM itself and may also include visits to places of detention in the company of the NPM. The objective is to help strengthen the NPM and thereby strengthen the protection afforded to persons deprived of their liberty against torture and other ill treatment. Each NPM-focused visit is therefore context-driven and is designed in such a way as to maximize its impact upon the work of the national body.
In situations where the State visited has yet to designate its NPM, as required by the OPCAT, the SPT will meet with State authorities, National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs), civil society and others in order to explore and remedy this failure to comply with international obligations.
When undertaking such visits, the SPT draws on:
- NPM Guidelines (CAT/OP/12/5)
- Approach to the Concept of Prevention (CAT/OP/12/6)
- Analytical self-assessment tool for NPMs (CAT/OP/1)
- Its other published papers relevant to the effective establishment and functioning of NPMs.
Following NPM Advisory visits, the SPT produces two visit reports, one to the NPM and the other to the State party, both of which remain confidential unless the addressee determines otherwise, and both of which form the basis of an ongoing constructive dialogue, in accordance with established OPCAT principles.
OPCAT advisory visits
An OPCAT advisory visit is devised to help States parties in fully implement their obligations set out in the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (OPCAT). They are short visits, focussing on high-level talks with senior government officials of the relevant ministries and bodies, as well as civil society representatives and any other relevant entities.